- Can I use Stripe Atlas for my WordPress plugin business?
- Yes, Stripe Atlas is an option. It forms a Delaware C Corporation by default, which is a different structure from the LLC discussed here. A C Corp is a US-taxable entity and requires a US corporate tax return, which can be more complex and costly than the LLC's Form 5472 filing. Atlas has recently started offering a Wyoming LLC option as well. The key difference is the ecosystem. With Atlas, you are generally streamlined into a specific set of banking partners. If that setup works for you, it is very efficient. If it does not, or if you are declined, you are left with a US entity and no bank account. Xavion's approach is broader, positioning you across a network of different institution types to increase placement probability.
- What if my WordPress plugin business gets rejected for a US bank account?
- Rejection is always a possibility. Banking is never guaranteed. If an application is rejected, the first step is to understand why. Reasons can range from a simple documentation error to a fundamental mismatch with the bank's risk appetite. For example, some institutions may be hesitant if your plugin serves a high-risk industry. If an application to one institution type, like a US fintech BaaS platform, is unsuccessful, the structure is still valid. We would then reassess and potentially apply to a different type of institution, such as a Puerto Rico IFE or a European EMI, which can still provide USD accounts in the company name. The US LLC remains the anchor for your business operations.
- Do I need to pay US sales tax if I sell my plugin from a US LLC?
- The question of sales tax on digital products in the US is complex and depends on economic nexus rules, which vary by state. However, many WordPress plugin businesses sidestep this issue by using a merchant of record (MoR) like Paddle or Lemon Squeezy. The MoR is the legal seller of the product; they handle all sales tax collection and remittance in exchange for a fee. Your LLC then receives a payout from the MoR. If you decide to sell direct using Stripe, you become responsible for sales tax compliance. This often requires integrating a service like TaxJar or Quaderno to calculate and file correctly. For many founders, using an MoR is the simpler path, even with a US LLC.
- Is a Wyoming or Delaware LLC better for a plugin business that might be acquired?
- If the likely acquirer is a large US software company, a Delaware entity might be slightly preferred as their legal team will be most familiar with Delaware law. However, an LLC's assets (like the code and customer list of your plugin business) can be acquired regardless of the state of formation. A Wyoming LLC can be converted to a Delaware LLC or C Corporation later in a process called domestication, should it become a requirement for a specific transaction. For most early-stage plugin businesses where an acquisition is a distant possibility rather than a formal plan, starting with the simplicity and lower cost of a Wyoming LLC is often the more pragmatic choice. You can cross that bridge when you come to it.
- How does this structure work if I sell plugins on ThemeForest or CodeCanyon?
- When you sell through a marketplace like Envato's ThemeForest or CodeCanyon, the marketplace acts as the merchant. They process the customer's payment, and you receive payouts from them. Having a US LLC with a US bank account can simplify receiving these payouts, especially in USD. You would provide your LLC's details and US account information to Envato for your author payouts. This avoids potential issues or high fees with receiving international wires to your personal home country bank account. It professionalises your author business and centralises your revenue in a US entity, which is cleaner for accounting. The core logic is the same: the LLC is a vehicle to more efficiently receive USD revenue.
- My partner is in another country, can we form a multi-member LLC?
- Yes, you can form a multi-member LLC. However, the tax and compliance situation changes significantly. A multi-member LLC is treated as a partnership by the IRS by default. This means the LLC itself must file a US partnership tax return (Form 1065), and each foreign partner may have an individual US tax filing obligation and a requirement to pay withholding tax, regardless of whether the income is ETBUS. This is substantially more complex and costly than the compliance for a foreign-owned single-member LLC (Form 5472). For this reason, if there are multiple founders, it is sometimes simpler for one founder to own the US LLC and have a separate legal agreement between the partners outside the US. This requires careful legal and tax advice.
- How do refunds and chargebacks for my plugin affect my US entity and bank account?
- High refund or chargeback rates are the single biggest operational threat to your payment processing relationship. Most processors, like Stripe, require rates to remain below 1%. Exceeding this threshold, even temporarily after a buggy update, can lead to a processor placing a high reserve on your funds (e.g., holding 25-50% for 90 days) or terminating your account. Your US bank itself is less concerned with individual refunds, but it will close your account if your payment processor drops you for fraud or excessive chargebacks. It is critical to offer clear support and honor your stated refund policy to keep these rates low.
- My plugin uses a freemium model. How does that impact banking and processor applications?
- A freemium model is common and well understood by underwriters, but it requires clear presentation. When you apply for a payment processor or bank account, your website must clearly distinguish between the free version and the paid premium features. Underwriters need to see what a customer is actually paying for. If it is unclear how your business generates revenue, your application may be flagged for manual review or declined. Be sure your pricing page explicitly lists the features unlocked by purchasing the premium plugin licence. This demonstrates a clear, legitimate source of funds.
- Can I sell lifetime licences for my WordPress plugin with this LLC structure?
- Yes, you can sell lifetime licences (LTDs) through a US LLC. However, be aware that processors view this model as higher risk than annual subscriptions. A lifetime deal front-loads revenue but creates a long-term support obligation with no recurring payment. This model can also attract a higher rate of chargebacks months or years later if the plugin is not maintained. Consequently, a processor may impose a larger and longer-lasting reserve on your account to cover this future risk. Framing it as a multi-year licence (e.g., 'Five Year Licence') instead of 'Lifetime' can sometimes mitigate this perception during underwriting.
- What happens if I decide to stop maintaining my plugin? Can I just dissolve the LLC?
- You can dissolve the LLC, but there is a proper sequence. First, you must manage your obligations to customers, especially those with annual or lifetime licences, as failing to do so could lead to chargebacks that complicate account closure. You must stop all sales and recurring billing. After settling any outstanding liabilities, you file Articles of Dissolution with the state of formation and submit final tax returns to the IRS if required. Simply abandoning the LLC without formally dissolving it can lead to penalties and prevent you from cleanly starting a new US business in the future.